Instacart: Retail disruption
Instacart S1 breakdown
👋 Hi, it’s Rohit Malhotra and welcome to Partner Growth Newsletter, my weekly newsletter doing deep dives into the fastest-growing startups and S1 briefs. Subscribe to join readers who get Partner Growth delivered to their inbox every Wednesday and Saturday morning.
Latest posts
If you’re new, not yet a subscriber, or just plain missed it, here are some of our recent editions.
Instacart S1 Breakdown
Instacart (ICRT) Stock Overview
Current Price: $32.12 (as of market close)
Market Cap: $8.44 billion
52-Week Range: $22.13 - $42.95
EPS (TTM): -20.86
IPO Details:
Instacart went public in September 2023, pricing its IPO at $30 per share and raising approximately $660 million. On its debut day, the stock surged to $42.95, marking a 43% increase from the IPO price. Since then, Instacart (trading under the ticker symbol "CART") has experienced fluctuations, reaching a high of around $42.95 before stabilizing within a lower range. Despite the initial excitement surrounding its IPO, Instacart continues to grapple with negative earnings, a common scenario for tech companies focused on long-term growth over immediate profitability.
Company Overview:
Instacart is a prominent player in the online grocery delivery market, connecting customers with personal shoppers who pick and pack groceries from various local stores. Its value proposition includes convenience, a broad selection of products, and partnerships with numerous grocery chains. Instacart's platform serves a significant number of customers across North America, positioning it as a key player in the growing e-commerce sector.
Recent Developments:
Expansion of Services: Instacart has recently expanded its delivery services to include a broader range of products, including household essentials and pharmaceuticals, to increase its market share and customer base.
Partnership with Major Retailers: The company has secured new partnerships with leading grocery chains and retailers, aiming to enhance its product offerings and improve delivery efficiency.
Technological Innovations: Instacart is investing in AI and machine learning to optimize its logistics and enhance the customer experience, including personalized shopping recommendations and improved delivery routing.
Sustainability Initiatives: Instacart is focusing on sustainability by working with partners to reduce packaging waste and promote eco-friendly practices within its supply chain.
Investor Sentiment:
Investors have mixed views on ICRT's future prospects. Bulls are optimistic about Instacart's growth potential, citing the expanding online grocery market, the company's strategic partnerships, and its technological advancements. They also point to Instacart's strong market position and the increasing demand for convenient grocery delivery services.
Conversely, bears are cautious due to Instacart's ongoing financial losses and negative EPS. Concerns are also raised about the competitive nature of the online grocery market and the company's ability to maintain profitability amid rising operational costs and market competition.
The Birth of Instacart
Imagine a world where grocery shopping is a breeze, where you can skip the long lines and have your groceries delivered right to your doorstep. In a world where almost everything could be delivered to your doorstep, groceries remained an outlier. This dream became a reality in 2012 when Apoorva Mehta, a former Amazon engineer, founded Instacart. Frustrated with the inconvenience of grocery shopping, Mehta set out to create a solution. Mehta envisioned a service that could bring the entire grocery store to your door with just a few taps on your smartphone. Fueled by this vision and leveraging his background in supply chain logistics, he built the initial version of Instacart, launching it in San Francisco, and initially handling deliveries himself. Little did he know, this was just the beginning of a revolutionary journey in the grocery delivery industry.
By focusing on the simplicity of an app-based interface and prioritizing user experience, Instacart started gaining traction. In just a few short years, it became synonymous with grocery delivery in urban areas. It was clear that Mehta had tapped into a significant market need—one that would only grow exponentially.
The Untapped Market Opportunity: A Trillion-Dollar Industry
The grocery market is a multi-billion-dollar industry, ripe for innovation. Traditional grocery shopping, while familiar, was begging for a modern twist. With a growing demand for convenience and the rise of e-commerce, Instacart tapped into a market opportunity that combined technology with everyday needs. The COVID-19 pandemic further accelerated this demand, making grocery delivery an essential service.
Total Market Size:
Total Addressable Market (TAM): Instacart estimates the total market opportunity to be approximately $1.1 trillion, representing the U.S. grocery spend in 2022.
Online Grocery Penetration: Online grocery sales grew significantly, from 3% of total grocery sales in 2019 to 12% in 2022. This market is expected to grow at a CAGR of 10% to 18% between 2022 and 2025, compared to 0% to 4% for offline sales.
Market by Fulfillment Options:
Pickup vs. Delivery: Within online grocery sales, 46% of total online sales are through pickup, while 54% are through delivery. Same-day delivery represents 55% of total delivery, and next-day delivery accounts for 45%.
Growth of Delivery Options: Instacart continues to expand delivery options to include next day, priority, and rapid delivery, catering to the growing demand for flexible delivery methods.
Advertising Market Opportunity:
CPG Advertising Spend: CPG brands in the U.S. spend approximately $200 billion annually on advertising, with nearly 25% of this spend through online channels.
Shift to Online Advertising: As grocery spend shifts online, advertising budgets are following. Approximately 82% of advertisers plan to increase their retail media spending, with a significant portion of this being directed towards online retail media networks like Instacart.
High ROI for Advertisers: Instacart's ads deliver more than a 15% incremental sales lift on average, with some cases achieving twice that, offering a high ROI for CPG brands.
Growth Drivers:
Retailer Expansion: Instacart aims to expand its market opportunity by enabling retailers to capture more orders through new fulfillment options and use cases, driving success both online and in-store.
Customer Engagement: Personalized, seamless shopping experiences across various use cases (weekly shop, bulk stock-up, convenience, special occasions) will continue to drive customer engagement and satisfaction.
Technology Integration: Instacart's technology solutions support omni-channel operations for retailers, helping them meet diverse customer needs and improve overall efficiency.
Product Overview
Instacart's product is simple yet powerful. Users can shop for groceries from their favorite local stores through the Instacart app or website. The platform connects customers with personal shoppers who pick, pack, and deliver the groceries. Beyond just groceries, Instacart also offers delivery for various other products, including household items, electronics, and even alcohol, making it a one-stop-shop for all essential needs.
Instacart’s product offerings are designed to support both customers and retailers through a comprehensive suite of eCommerce and fulfillment solutions:
Instacart Marketplace:
eCommerce Platform: Instacart Marketplace serves as the central platform for customers to shop from a wide range of retailers. It works with over 1,400 retail partners, representing more than 80,000 stores across North America. This platform is designed to provide a seamless shopping experience, allowing customers to browse, compare, and purchase items from multiple stores in one transaction.
Fulfillment Options: Instacart offers several delivery options to meet different customer needs:
Same-Day Delivery: This is the primary service offered by Instacart, enabling customers to receive their groceries within a few hours of placing an order.
Next-Day Delivery: For customers who plan ahead, Instacart provides the option to schedule deliveries for the next day.
Rapid Delivery: This service is designed for customers who need their items as quickly as possible, often within 30 minutes.
Instacart Enterprise:
Custom Retailer Solutions: Instacart Enterprise offers white-label solutions for retailers, allowing them to operate their own branded online storefronts while leveraging Instacart’s technology and logistics network.
Omni-Channel Capabilities: Instacart’s technology supports retailers in offering a seamless omni-channel experience, integrating online and offline shopping to improve customer satisfaction and loyalty.
Advertising and Analytics:
Instacart Ads: This platform allows CPG (Consumer Packaged Goods) brands to advertise their products directly on Instacart’s platform, reaching a highly targeted audience. The advertising tools are designed to deliver strong ROI, with some campaigns achieving more than 15% incremental sales lift.
Analytics and Insights: Retailers and brands can access detailed analytics and insights through Instacart’s platform, helping them make data-driven decisions to optimize their sales and marketing strategies.
Business Offerings:
Instacart Business: This service caters to business customers, offering features like centralized ordering, shared lists, invoicing, and bulk purchasing options. It’s designed to meet the unique needs of businesses that require regular and large-volume grocery deliveries.
Business Model
Instacart operates on a multi-faceted business model. They generate revenue through delivery fees, subscription services (Instacart Express), and partnerships with retailers. Retailers pay Instacart for the service, benefitting from increased online sales without the hassle of setting up their own delivery infrastructure. Additionally, Instacart earns through advertising placements, providing brands with prime visibility on their platform. In 2022, 71% of revenue came from transactions (up 43% YoY) and 29% from advertising and other (up 29% YoY). The revenue mix is consistent in the Jun-23 quarter.
Instacart's business model is structured around multiple revenue streams, primarily driven by its core marketplace operations and its advertising platform.
1. Revenue Streams:
Transaction Fees:
Retailer Fees: Instacart charges retailers a fee for every transaction processed through its platform. This fee is typically a percentage of the total order value, which varies depending on the partnership terms.
Customer Fees: Customers are charged delivery fees and service fees on each order. These fees vary based on the order size, delivery time, and customer membership status (e.g., Instacart Express members receive free delivery on orders over a certain amount).
Instacart Ads:
Advertising Fees: Brands pay Instacart to promote their products on the platform. These ads are integrated into the shopping experience, allowing brands to reach customers at the point of purchase. The ads platform has become a significant revenue stream for Instacart, contributing to its profitability.
2. Membership Model:
Instacart Express:
Subscription Revenue: Instacart offers a subscription service called Instacart Express, which provides customers with benefits such as free delivery on orders over a certain amount and reduced service fees. The subscription is priced at $99 per year or $9.99 per month, generating recurring revenue for the company.
3. Fulfillment Operations:
Shopper Network:
Instacart’s fulfillment is handled by a network of personal shoppers who pick, pack, and deliver groceries. Shoppers are independent contractors who are paid per order they fulfill. This flexible labor model allows Instacart to scale its operations quickly based on demand without the fixed costs associated with a full-time workforce.
Partnerships with Retailers:
Instacart partners with a wide range of retailers, allowing them to leverage Instacart's platform for online sales and delivery services. These partnerships are key to Instacart's ability to offer a broad selection of products and drive transaction volume.
4. Technology Platform:
Proprietary Technology:
Instacart’s business model is underpinned by its technology platform, which integrates order management, inventory, payments, and logistics. This technology enables Instacart to manage millions of transactions efficiently, optimize delivery routes, and provide a seamless customer experience.
Data and Analytics:
Instacart uses data analytics to optimize its operations and provide insights to retail partners. This includes demand forecasting, shopper efficiency analysis, and personalized marketing for customers, all of which contribute to higher customer retention and increased transaction value.
Management Team
Instacart’s management team is a blend of seasoned executives with deep expertise in technology, business, and operations. Their diverse backgrounds and strategic vision have been instrumental in steering Instacart through its rapid expansion and evolving market demands.
1. Apoorva Mehta (Founder & Former CEO)
Apoorva Mehta, the visionary behind Instacart, began his career as an engineer at Amazon, where he gained valuable insights into e-commerce logistics and customer service. His frustration with grocery shopping led him to conceptualize Instacart. Mehta’s leadership and entrepreneurial spirit drove the company’s early growth, turning it from a small startup into a major player in the grocery delivery space. Under his guidance, Instacart secured significant funding and expanded its market reach.
2. Fidji Simo (CEO)
Fidji Simo took over as CEO in August 2021, bringing a wealth of experience from her previous role as the Head of the Facebook App. At Facebook, Simo was instrumental in driving user growth and engagement, overseeing teams responsible for the core product experience. Her expertise in scaling digital platforms and her background in consumer technology make her a strategic fit for leading Instacart. Simo’s leadership is focused on enhancing user experience, expanding product offerings, and driving innovation.
3. Sandeep Goyal (Chief Financial Officer)
Sandeep Goyal joined Instacart as CFO, bringing extensive experience in financial management from his time at Uber and Goldman Sachs. His expertise in financial strategy, operations, and fundraising has been crucial in navigating Instacart’s complex financial landscape. Goyal’s role involves overseeing financial planning, investor relations, and ensuring the company’s fiscal health as it scales.
4. Laura Jones (Chief Operating Officer)
Laura Jones, COO at Instacart, has a robust background in operations and supply chain management. Prior to joining Instacart, Jones held executive roles at companies like Walmart and Target, where she was known for her expertise in streamlining operations and enhancing efficiency. Her role at Instacart involves optimizing the logistics and delivery processes, ensuring that the company can meet growing customer demands effectively.
5. Eric Lempel (Chief Marketing Officer)
Eric Lempel, CMO of Instacart, comes with a strong background in marketing and brand strategy. Before Instacart, Lempel worked as the Global Head of Marketing at PlayStation, where he led successful marketing campaigns and brand initiatives. His role at Instacart focuses on driving customer acquisition, enhancing brand visibility, and developing innovative marketing strategies to attract and retain users.
6. Sarah Tavel (Board Member)
Sarah Tavel, a board member at Instacart, is a prominent venture capitalist with a history of successful investments in tech and consumer startups. Her previous roles at Benchmark Capital and Greylock Partners have equipped her with deep industry knowledge and strategic insights. Tavel’s involvement in the board provides valuable guidance on growth strategies and market positioning.
7. Mark Schaaf (Chief Technology Officer)
Mark Schaaf, CTO of Instacart, brings a wealth of experience in technology and engineering. With a background in building scalable tech solutions at companies like Amazon and Microsoft, Schaaf’s role is pivotal in advancing Instacart’s technology infrastructure. His focus is on enhancing the platform’s capabilities, improving user experience, and driving technological innovation.
Instacart’s management team is a powerhouse of expertise, combining leadership in technology, operations, finance, and marketing. Each member brings a unique set of skills and experiences, contributing to the company’s dynamic growth and strategic vision. With such a talented team at the helm, Instacart is well-positioned to continue its leadership in the grocery delivery industry and to drive future innovations.
Investments and Ownership: Fueling Growth with Significant Capital
Instacart has been a magnet for investment, drawing in substantial capital from a range of high-profile investors. These investments have played a crucial role in scaling the company’s operations, expanding its market presence, and driving innovation.
Seed Round (2012): $2.3M from Kleiner Perkins and Andreessen Horowitz; helped set the stage for rapid development and early growth.
Series A (2013): $8M led by Sequoia Capital; expanded services beyond San Francisco.
Series B (2014): $44M led by Andreessen Horowitz; enhanced technology and operations.
Series C (2015): $135M led by ICONIQ Capital; expanded retail partnerships.
Series D (2017): $400M at a $3.4B valuation; scaled operations. Notable investors included Coatue Management and the previous backers such as Sequoia Capital and Andreessen Horowitz.
Series E (2018): $600M at a $7.6B valuation from General Catalyst and Kleiner Perkins; focused on tech advancements.
Series F (2020): $265M at a $17.7B valuation from D1 Capital Partners and Dragoneer Investment Group; scaled for COVID-19 demand.
Series G (2021): $265M at a $39B valuation from Mubadala Investment Company and Andreessen Horowitz; expanded tech and team.
Total Funding and Valuation:
As of the latest data, Instacart has raised over $2.4 billion in total funding. The company’s valuation has seen dramatic increases, reflecting its growth and potential. The strategic investments have enabled Instacart to innovate, scale rapidly, and maintain its competitive edge in the grocery delivery sector.
Stakeholder Chart:
Competition
In the competitive landscape of grocery delivery, Instacart faces formidable opponents like Amazon Fresh, Walmart Grocery, and Shipt.
Instacart’s Advantages Over Competitors
Amazon Fresh: Instacart's local store partnerships offer a wider selection of local brands, and its personal shopper model provides a more tailored shopping experience.
Walmart Grocery: Instacart delivers faster and offers a broader range of products from multiple stores in one order.
Shipt: Instacart features a diverse network of retailers and emphasizes advanced technology for a better user experience.
Peapod: Instacart’s scalable model and innovative technology enhance customer experience and reach compared to Peapod’s traditional approach.
FreshDirect: Instacart provides a broader product range and shopping flexibility with its multiple-store partnerships, surpassing FreshDirect’s more limited selection.
Instacart’s success in a competitive landscape is driven by its strategic partnerships with local retailers, its flexibility in shopping options, and its focus on technology and user experience. By differentiating itself with a personal shopper model, rapid delivery, and a diverse retail network, Instacart has carved out a unique position in the grocery delivery market. While competitors like Amazon Fresh, Walmart Grocery, Shipt, Peapod, and FreshDirect each have their strengths, Instacart’s comprehensive and customer-centric approach continues to set it apart in the industry.
Financial Stats
Instacart’s financial journey is nothing short of impressive. With annual revenues crossing billions, the company has shown exponential growth. In 2021 alone, Instacart’s gross revenue was estimated to be over $1.83 billion. The company continues to invest in technology, expanding its reach and improving efficiency, all while aiming for profitability in the near future.
Revenue
2022: $2.55 billion (increase of 39% YoY)
2021: $1.83 billion
Net Income
2022: $428 million (Net income margin: 17%)
2021: -$73 million (Net loss margin: -4%)
Gross Profit
2022: $1.83 billion (Gross margin: 72%)
2021: $1.29 billion (Gross margin: 71%)
Quarterly Revenue & Gross Profit per Order ($)
Operating Income
2022: $81 million (Operating margin: 3%)
2021: -$74 million (Operating loss margin: -4%)
EBITDA
2022: $386 million (EBITDA margin: 15%)
2021: -$39 million
Cash and Cash Equivalents
June 2023: $2.07 billion
Quarterly Orders and AOV ($)
Key Metrics:
Order Frequency: 1.95 orders per week (up 7% YoY)
Customer Base: 7.7 million active customers
Gross Transaction Volume (GTV): $29.4 billion in 2022
Final thoughts
Instacart's journey from a startup to a major player in the online grocery delivery market reflects its ability to capitalize on a growing industry while continuously innovating its services. Despite its success in capturing significant market share and expanding its services, Instacart faces ongoing challenges, particularly in achieving sustainable profitability amidst stiff competition and operational costs. The company’s strategic focus on partnerships, technological advancements, and expanding its product offerings positions it well for future growth. However, investor sentiment remains mixed, with optimism about its market potential tempered by concerns over its financial losses. As Instacart continues to navigate the complexities of the e-commerce landscape, its ability to balance growth with profitability will be crucial in determining its long-term success.